Why is this the best time of the year ? Is it because it’s Eid-al-adha ? Well, the official definition says we’re to celebrate Eid Al-Adha because Abraham was willing to sacrifice his son to affirm the strength of his faith in God. Some of the Muslim, Jews, and Christians I know are willing to start fist-fights over whether his son’s name was Ismaeil or Isaac; like it makes a difference. Could it be that a delusional man in a moment of temporary insanity listened to the voices in his head and was about to murder his son ? No, that is no reason to celebrate. Not when we have news of people actually throwing live babies in dumpsters.
Should I celebrate Christmas because Jesus was born ? A quote my old school headmaster used to be fond of (For God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes in him might not perish but might have eternal life). Could it be Mary needed an explanation of her pregnancy out of wedlock, and having the son of God seemed like a good excuse at the time. The Catholic church back when it actually had power initiated the crusades, and in our times George W. still claims to be on a crusade in Jesus’s name while invading someone else’s country. That is no reason to celebrate.
Should I then celebrate Chanukah because the Jewish second temple was rebuilt (and later destroyed) ? Again the answer is no, because on that same mountain (the temple mount) Muslims built the Aqsa mosque, and according to the book of Mark Jesus prayed there. This significance of Jerusalem to the 3 religions are part of why this city never found peace.
Should I celebrate because I get time off from work ? No, I get a weekend every week. Every day my 2 sisters and I go to work, come home at different times, have dinner, and go to our rooms, often never seeing each other all day or even all week.
Only on Eid do my parents travel to Amman from Ramallah, and my brother travels here from the US. The whole family comes together. Call it Eid, Christmas, Chanukah, “the holidays”, “time off”. It’s a glue that helps keep us together.
Why is Eid so important to our Garbage man ? Every Eid, the city garbage collectors knock on our door, and ask for their Eidiyeh (holiday bonus); every year my dad obliges them. The one Eid where my parents couldn’t make it to Amman, I answered the garbage man’s knock instead. He asked the usual question. kul 3am wu intu bkheir (happy holidays), and then something that amounts to “Where is my money?” My answer was a little different than my father’s however. The apple fell far from the tree. I told the garbage man, I pay income tax, sales tax, and a garbage collection fee on my utility bill every month, and that what I pay goes to the Greater Amman Municipilaty (GAM), and they are the ones responsible for giving him his bonus. Too much information. He asks “where’s your dad ?”. I close the door. So why doesn’t GAM pay its workers a bonus ? and has them instead knocking on people’s door’s asking for money like beggars ?
Am I being stingy or evil by not giving an impoverished worker a few JDs ? I don’t think so. I would gladly spend 50JD to invite some friends to a meal, or give them a gift. Yet I won’t give 1 JD to a beggar who actually needs it. Where is the logic in that ?
I remember this one summer (about 20 years ago) where my family along with my cousins were going to swim and have lunch at the American Colony Hotel in Jerusalem. Just before we left the house, the doorbell rang. It was a beggar saying something about not being able to feed his family, and having not smelled bread for I don’t know how long. As a kid I cried and cried and cried over this. Here we were without a care in the world about to go swimming, while this man was trying to feed his children. Where is the justice ?
So, what happened ? How did that cute kid turn into me ? As reality set in, and the innocence faded; I realised I am only a man. I will not be able to save the world. So I made a compromise. I will try to be good to the people I know, and that will be enough. Enough for what ? Enough to satisfy what is left of that child who once cried for a beggar more than 20 years ago.




26 Users Commented In This Post
Posted from
12-25-2007 at 14:28:38
I celebrate this time sleeping regardless the occasion!
Posted from
12-25-2007 at 17:16:37
You have other ways of helping those in need, a great example is taking care of a child/family (tabani yateem) in somewhere like Gaza. Just sending them a bit of money each month and keeping in contact with them, is better than giving the money to beggars.
Posted from
12-25-2007 at 21:19:01
as weird as that sounds, but i still believe that one man can change a lot of things, if we can just stop thinking that one person can;t change a thing we will achieve way more than you can imagine.
but again, whatever works for you!
Posted from
12-26-2007 at 00:30:00
Chikapappi, if cash is king, then sleep is queen !
Khaled, somehow I’d rather spend the money on myself or someone I know rather than an orphan far away.
Maioush, I guess that’s the other way to look at it. It’s like voting in an election, how much difference does one vote make ? Yet, a million votes are just one million one person votes !
Posted from
12-26-2007 at 07:46:46
“a million votes are just one million one person votes”
True, and you are actually doing it without realizing or admitting it. You said you’re good to the people you know and this is enough for you. And it is enough, if you look at it - not everyone is good to the people they know. So you’re doing much better than a good chunk of the population.
Posted from
12-26-2007 at 09:44:50
Why is it that people find it refreshing to trash other people’s beliefs like that… I have no idea… I thought I knew you better than that…
Oh by the way, you were not so good to everyone you knew in this post… I considered myself a person who knew you… even if it were only on blog posts…
Posted from
12-26-2007 at 09:49:01
Mkilany, basically we disagree on the meaning of “respecting someone else”.
This is often misused. People have different opinions. What needs to be respected is their right to have different opinions, and the people themselves.
Respecting their ideas is optional if you happen to agree with them. I do not respect you any less for disagreeing with me. I understand if you don’t feel the same way.
Posted from
12-26-2007 at 09:50:53
KJ, indeed if all of us are good to everyone we know, then everyone will have someone to be nice to them since everyone knows someone.
Posted from
12-26-2007 at 10:18:45
Mkilany, just to add to that, almost all the people I know are Muslims. I don’t have to tell you how many times the Quran has the statement:(لعنة الله على الكافرين) (God curse the unbelievers). This is a direct disagreement with my belief of Atheism/Agnosticism. I don’t take it as a personal insult. It’s a disagreement with my ideas, that’s all.
Posted from
12-26-2007 at 12:51:27
I think I will be fired today… for not doing anything…
This discussion will take forever, but the thing is if we were disagreeing on something that is not important like, the color of a building, or the taste of a sandwich… I wouldn’t be offended… We can disagree on that all day and it won’t matter… Your argument has grounds only in that case…
But what if I express an opinion in something that you think highly of, like your family… or whatever, if I curse them in a post that would you respect my ideas and take it my own personal opinion!!
When you talk about it in this manner, I get more and more convinced that the difference between Atheists and religious people is that Atheists only think of Atheism as something more of a thought system, a way of interpreting everything… just like creative thinking, logical thinking or whatever, to us Ibrahim and Mary are something that is totally different… role models is an understatement…
Even if you think that they are un-real, you don’t have the right to insult them… You have the right to keep it to yourself but expressing it just like that simply insults what is held sacred by Muslims, Christians and Jews, thinking that it shouldn’t is irrelevant, because it simply does…
You understate it to a simple disagreement as if we are talking about a distant event on MARS…
We are always sold this co-existence from philosophers that seem out of touch with reality and human emotions, that you can disagree on everything and you should respect that, well, I don’t think so… I simply do not respect other people bashing what we hold high under the excuse of the right to express ideas…
Posted from
12-26-2007 at 13:40:28
Then wait until you get home. I’m here and will be happy to discuss this with you as long as you are willing, and able. I do not consider old posts uncommentable like many bloggers. I am about to go to work myself.
mkilany, I agree with you about my family. That is personal by definition. About considering anyone who disagrees with your religious beliefs disrespecting you personally, we have to agree to disagree.
The problem is that you’re encouraging political correctness and insincere false politeness. If I will be damned, then I will be damned for who I am, for I will not hide it. I am as offended by Islam as I am by Christianity and for the same reason. At the height of the Islamic empire, they got in a ship and attacked Spain. They weren’t defending themselves. They were the aggressors, no better than the crusaders. That is enough proof for me. No religion worth believing in can be spread by the sword (or an F15).
I don’t speak for all Atheists, but yes, I value questioning everything. The less proof the more questions. As a role model I question Abraham’s willingness to kill his own son regardless who asked him to. As a role model, I question that Jesus is the son of God because it just doesn’t make sense. The god described in the bible doesn’t need to send a human son and have him die for people’s sins. He can just forgive them their sins period! It sounds suspiciously like a fairy tale.
I have as much right to express my disagreement with Islamic Theology as Muslims have to express their disagreement with Christian theology. You in turn have the right to dislike me for doing this.
It is even more distant an event than Mars. We have photographs of Mars, we can track it. No one has ever seen Abraham or Mary.
Then you missed my point, or think it’s irrelevant. I was illustrating why even as an Agnostic/Atheist Eid is still important to me. Discounting what muslims/christians/jews believe about Eid/Christmas/Chanukah respectively wasn’t the point, just a transit if you will.
Co-existence is about you and I not attacking each other, and being civil. It is certainly not about agreeing about every belief. If someone is a muslim I do not hold that fact against them. Instead I will observe their actions and decide if this is someone I would want to associate with.
Oddly it is the ones who least enjoy this type of dialogue who engage in it the most.
Posted from
12-26-2007 at 16:06:25
Hani,
Exactly my point, I thought it was obvious, yes, religion is personal if you choose the word personal instead of important it doesn’t matter… its the same at the end of the day, it is important to the point you call personal… more than family to believers, why else would they die for religion!
People get offended when you bash their role models and religion… it’s as simple as that… transit or not…
Believers don’t think of it as a distant event on MARS, just because they can’t see it!! Your standards differ to an extent you’re not even able to see it from the other point of view…
As for religions “worth believing”, we live in the real world… you can live in US la la land, but here on planet Earth people get killed for oil, power, beliefs, love and a million other thing every single day… so better wake up and smell the Athiest gunpowder…
Posted from
12-27-2007 at 01:17:17
Despair, and lack of any better options.
I understand enough about the other point of view to realize it’s not for me. In fact I dedicated a post to this issue. See (God should have studied marketing).
So walking on water, flying from one city to another on the back of an animal, virgin births, splitting the red sea, these are all the real world ? but just me wishing for a peaceful religion is la la land ? Regardless, we are both dead-set on our religious beliefs or lack thereof, and that won’t change.
Yet, I used the word “fairy tale”; You used the phrase “la la land”. It seems our opinions of each other’s religious beliefs are quite parallel. What I tried and failed to convince you of is that it is better for me and you to bring out these opinions in the open, because hiding views this “important” would be a form of deception, and I am just not fond of masks in any form. As you can see I use my real name, and picture. I don’t try to withhold my background or beliefs, my strengths and weaknesses.
What I didn’t get about your statement though is why you said “US la la land”. Why US ? Is that supposed to make it negative or simply imply that my ideas are foreign. I know they are. Still, Americans would be insulted by the implication particularly since most of them are Christian and believe in God. Even the ones that don’t will not share my views on most things. Hey we’re talking about a people who decided to re-elect George W. Bush for a second term.
In any case. I am who I am and I don’t see that changing. I am vocal about my beliefs because I do not think they are anything to be ashamed of. Still, I’m glad we had this discussion because now you know where I stand, and are free to either ignore, discuss, or stand in opposition (istinkar). Regardless you will always be welcome here.
Posted from
12-27-2007 at 10:45:39
Hani,
“Despair and lack of any better option” to state that only desperate people are religious, now that’s very enlightening! So you will not find any successful religious person on the face of the earth who is willing to sacrifice everything for religion… Sorry Hani but I thought you would use a more logical approach…
I’m curious, did you ever believe in any religion at any point of time in your life?
I didn’t give it much thought when I said US LaLa land, but I guess the US represents everything that is material to me and many others… a source of such thoughts if you will… but that was beside the point, “just a transit if you will”…
The point is that conflicts arise when two opposite ideologies exist, it will always be the case… I don’t apologize for it or deny it… When necessary people will die for what they believe in, if it is something people believe in with all their hearts and minds…
Some people value the fact that ohters are willing to sacrifice everything for their cause, maybe even envy them for that…
” ربما يود الذين كفروا لو كانوا مسلمين ذرهم ياكلوا ويتمتعوا ويلههم الامل فسوف يعلمون”
While others would think its a total waste or an act of despair and lack of options… So I guess we live in two very different worlds and will disagree indefinitely…
Posted from
12-27-2007 at 11:07:58
That’s a misquote, only desperate people would die for religion, that has no implication on whether they’re religious or not. It’s not about finding an exception mkilany. It’s about the majority of people who do sacrifice their lives in the name of religion. People like the ones who bombed the hotels in Amman, or the ones who bomb buses in Jerusalem.
More examples of people dying for their religion in yesterday’s paper. Suicide bombers in Iraq killed 35 people. One of the bombings was right in the middle of a funeral procession. Surely these are not your role-models mkilany. They are murderers, and yet they think they’re going to heaven. Hah! The ones you are thinking of only exist in books.
Yes, when I was too young to know any better.
As I see it:
Upto age 10, you simply assume your parents and teachers opinions.
Between 10 and 20 you realise your parents and teachers don’t know everything and look at other sources.
Between 20 and 30, you begin forming your own opinions.
Between 30 and 60, the die is cast, and it’s difficult to change your views.
After 60, the cycle reverses except instead of parents and teachers it’s children and caretakers.
This is of course all my subjective opinion, not science.
Materialistic yes, but we are just as Materialistic,In some ways worse. They don’t have the “show-off” gene we have if you know what I mean. Diversity of opinions is a strength not a weakness. Total conformity can only lead to stagnation.
Yet, we live in the same city. I agree, we will disagree indefinitely on Religion, Politics, and their importance.
Posted from
12-27-2007 at 19:08:36
You express yourself very well Hani. I like the discussion going on between you and M Kilani.
Posted from
12-28-2007 at 01:01:15
Kind of you to say 7aki, but most of the phrases I use aren’t original although I don’t realize it at the time. I will often out of curiosity google a phrase after writing it to see if I plagiarized it unconsciously.
For instance after I wrote (I am who I am) to mkilany, I googled it and it seems God beat me to it. He said it to Moses ! How appropriate :)
It’s a sign, I must repent. I must repent. Not !!!
Posted from
12-28-2007 at 05:23:57
lol. You are funny!
Posted from
12-29-2007 at 12:46:53
“Only desperate people would die for religion”
“The ones you are thinking of only exist in books.”
The world is full of people who die for religion, fighting aggression all over the world, Palestine, Kashmir, Afghanistan, Iraq, Chechnya, Bosnia… many have arrived at such destinations from distant Arab Countries for one reason only that is religion, it is the only thing that drives a man from Jordan to travel and die with men in Chechneya, brothers in religion no more… to state that the majority are desperate men is your personal judgment, such generalizations, turn my stomache…
I hate it when I see people look high on noble people regardless of the amount of money they posses or the way they dress…
Even if some of the people who are in the front lines are poor, so what? The majority of people on planet earth are poor…
Do you really think that their lives are valued less… well judging by your words, maybe you do… I’m sure they don’t…?
To them their lives are as important as any… Don’t they dream of better lives… do they love their children any less, do they despise their families and friends to the point that they will just kill themselves, travel far, face imputations and unbelievable hardships?!?
Another thing is lets not pick and choose, some may die in the name of religion (for the wrong causes), you know I’m not talking about those (e.g. Amman bombings & SOME of Iraq’s)…
Palestine Bombings are a totally different story… Another lengthy debate to say the least…
Posted from
12-29-2007 at 13:37:45
Yes I know you’re not talking about them, but you just decided that you will only call a person a Muslim if they sacrificed their life according to your idea of Islam ? It’s not your choice to make. The important thing is that they think they are dying to go to heaven and this illustrates exactly what’s wrong with these religions. People behaving nonsensically because they think there is an afterlife. They better be very sure, are you ?
Regardless, is a piece of land any piece of land anywhere worth a life ? is it worth your life ?
Posted from
12-29-2007 at 17:03:33
We were discussing if it those people are desperate or not… You choose to shift focus into me…
Yes, I am sure there is an afterlife… Are you sure there isn’t?
“Regardless, is a piece of land any piece of land anywhere worth a life ? is it worth your life ?”
You still don’t see it, do you… It’s not about a piece of land… a piece of land has nothing to do with it… its our belief “religion” that is worth it… Is it worth my life, yes… Am I at that point in my life where I’m brave enough to take that step… I hope someday I will be ready to die for what I believe in…
Posted from
12-29-2007 at 17:09:33
Good, you’re way ahead of me, my point was that if you believed your own words, you wouldn’t be here right now, and I’m just glad you still are.
Not only that but the mosques are still full of young men who have decent jobs and families they care for too much to do something as foolish as going to a foreign country and dying like a dog for someone else’s cause. The point was as long as this is the case they won’t be desperate (brave isn’t the word) enough to try to seek the fantasy called heaven, but I think we’ve come full circle here.
Posted from
12-29-2007 at 19:38:08
I hate playing with words, this is exactly what my parents called جدال بيزنطي or “an argument for the sake of argument”…
Sacrificing everything for a cause is brave, you want to call it desperate… go ahead… Che Givara was a very desperate man, The Islamic Armies, every Samurai that wanted to achieve Nirvana along with all the Japanese Kamikaze in WWII… you want to call them a bunch of desperate people go ahead, I’m not going for it…
You want to call facing death for a cause an act of desperation please do… I hope you’re happy with your full circle… cause from where I stand it doesn’t even look like a circle, much more like a distorted rectangle
Sweet dreams
Posted from
12-29-2007 at 20:15:18
By the way, don’t say that you’re a coward, I think you should be beheaded… but I don’t think you’re a coward… just drop those last stupid 7 comments… and put my original comment up… and replace خرابيش الجاج with a “distorted rectangle” or something…
Posted from
12-29-2007 at 20:53:01
Done.
I still don’t understand this Che thing that a lot of bloggers seemed to be obsessed with, and will not admire samurai and kamikaze or any warriors for that matter.
Coward is not an insult for me. Most brave (foolish) heroes are dead. I’d rather be alive.
Full circle referred to you and I having expressed the full spectrum of our views on this subject meaning that if we continue, we will simply repeat what was already said.
Posted from
12-29-2007 at 22:37:00
Everyone dies… You better be sure that that human beings are just a complex set of coincidences… That men with excellent credentials, known for their honesty and wise decisions were telling lies that contradict everything they stood for… men who lived their whole lives despising lies and suffering enormously…
Sharing Is Caring.....